Jakarta –
The panel of judges granted singer Vidi Aldiano‘s exception in a lawsuit regarding alleged copyright infringement of the song entitled ‘Nuansa Bening’. The judge stated that the lawsuit filed by Keenan Nasution and Rudi Pekerti as the creators of the song ‘Nuansa Bening’ was unacceptable.
“So the granting of the exception resulted in or made the plaintiff’s claim unacceptable. So in this case the Panel of Judges did not enter into the substance of the case,” said Central Jakarta District Court (PN Jakpus) spokesperson Muhammad Firman Akbar to reporters, Friday (21/11/2025).
Firman said the lawsuit could not be accepted due to formal defects or lack of parties. The judge believes that the 31 concert organizers and three digital music platforms mentioned in the lawsuit should also be named as co-defendants.
SCROLL TO CONTINUE WITH CONTENT
“But this digital platform is not a party to the lawsuit. So it makes the plaintiff’s lawsuit formally flawed,” said Firman.
“In this lawsuit the plaintiff sued 31 live concert allegedly performed by the defendant. But these 31 concerts, the show organizers or event organizerIt’s not a party. “According to the Panel of Judges, the 31 concerts, the concert organizers, should be sued,” he added.
For information, there are three lawsuits alleging copyright infringement filed against Oxavia Aldiano alias Vidi Aldiano. The first lawsuit is registered with case number 51/Pdt.Sus-HKI/Cipta/2025/PN Niaga Jkt.Pst dated May 21 2025.
This lawsuit was filed by Keenan Nasution and Rudi Pekerti as the creators of the song ‘Nuansa Bening’. They asked Vidi to pay compensation of IDR 24.5 billion for alleged copyright infringement for using the song ‘Nuansa Bening’ commercially in 31 performances or live concert without permission.
The second lawsuit is registered with case number 73/Pdt.Sus-HKI/Cipta/2025/PN Niaga Jkt.Pst dated June 30 2025 by Keenan Nasution and Rudi Pekerti. They asked Vidi to pay compensation of IDR 3 billion for alleged copyright infringement for distributing the song ‘Nuansa Bening’ on three digital music platforms, namely Apple Music, YouTube Music and Spotify, without permission.
The third lawsuit is registered with case number 74/Pdt.Sus-HKI/Cipta/2025/PN Niaga Jkt.Pst dated July 3 2025 by Rudi Pekerti. In this lawsuit, Rudi also asked Vidi to pay compensation of IDR 900 million and change the name of the creator of the song ‘Nuansa Bening’ to the names Rudi and Keenan on three digital music platforms, namely Apple Music, YouTube Music and Spotify.
(sib/jbr)