“`html
Sister of woman Killed in oise Obtains Dismissal of Investigating Judge
Table of Contents
By invented Reporter | %%dateline_location%% – 2025/06/30 12:37:38
This is a new step in his fight to have the dysfunctions recognized in this case. The sister of a woman killed in the Oise in 2017 obtained the dismissal of an investigating judge before the disciplinary training of the Superior Council of the Magistracy (CSM), she announced Monday, June 30.
Bénédicte Belair had been found dead at her home in Pont-Sainte-maxence on April 4, 2017. The investigation had initially dismissed a feminicide. President of the National Federation of women’s Victims,Sylvaine Grévin,the victim’s sister,denounces in particular “A sloppy investigation”,“favoring an accidental death in defiance of a proven context of domestic violence” and the destruction of seals while judicial facts was underway.
In July 2024, she seized the CSM against the prosecutor and the investigating judge of the time. She obtained that her complaint against the investigating judge was transmitted to the disciplinary council of the magistrates of the siege, but not that concerning the prosecutor, told the Agency France-Presse (AFP) Olivier Morice, one of the complainant’s lawyers. Many CSM referrals by litigants rarely lead.
Article reserved for our subscribers
The state assigned to justice after the suspicious death of a woman in the Oise
A Gendarme My Under Exam
“The conditions under which the hearing of the civil party took place (…) and the exhumation of Bénédicte Belair’s body was carried out (…) are likely to receive a disciplinary qualification due to a breach of the obligation of delicacy “ can we read in the decision of the CSM request admission commission, sent to AFP by Mme Grévin.
Sylvaine Grévin explains that he was “Traumatized” incidentally in which the investigating judge had questioned her and stresses that the magistrate had not notified the family of the exhumation of the Bénédicte Belair body to make a new autopsy, in 2020. If he is surprised by the prosecutor, because the State was condemned “Because of his fault” for the destruction of seals, Me Morice was delighted with a “Rare decision” for the investigating judge.
After various twists and turns, Bénédicte Belair’s companion was finally indicted in January 2023 for aggravated violence against him, between January 2015 and April 2017. He was also placed under the status of witness assisted for “murder”. For the destruction of seals, The state was sentenced in May 2021 for “gross negligence”.
Mme Grévin had also filed a complaint for non-assistance to a person in danger against a gendarme intervened at his sister’s home a few days before his death, a complaint recently classified. Another gendarme, who had led the preliminary investigation, was indicted for false in public writing in january.
Article reserved for our subscribers
“(On) alive”, on Canal+: orphans after feminicide, children “twice sacrificed”
Understanding the case: Key Points
This case revolves around the death of Bénédicte Belair in 2017 and the subsequent investigation, which her sister, Sylvaine Grévin, felt was mishandled. Grévin’s actions highlight the challenges faced by families seeking justice in cases of suspected feminicide. The dismissal of the investigating judge represents a significant, albeit rare, victory for the family.
The key issues include the initial dismissal of feminicide as a potential cause of death, the alleged destruction of evidence (seals), and the conduct of the investigating judge. The involvement of the CSM underscores the seriousness of the allegations against the judicial officials involved.
Frequently Asked Questions
- What happened to Bénédicte Belair?
- Bénédicte Belair was found dead at her home in Pont-Sainte-Maxence on April 4, 2017. The initial investigation dismissed it as a feminicide.
- Why did Sylvaine Grévin seize the CSM?
- Sylvaine Grévin,Bénédicte Belair’s sister,seized the CSM (Superior Council of the Magistracy) against the prosecutor and the investigating judge due to a sloppy investigation and the destruction of seals.
- What was the outcome of the CSM referral?
- Sylvaine Grévin obtained that her complaint against the investigating judge was transmitted to the disciplinary council of the magistrates of the siege.
