Paul Harney’s Family Battles Eviction in Dublin’s Stressed Housing Market
A family in Dublin, Ireland, may be forced from their home of 10 years due to mounting financial pressures and limited rental housing options. After multiple failed attempts to find alternative accommodation, Paul Harney and his family face imminent eviction from their apartment.
The Family’s Struggles
Paul Harney, 42, resides in a three-bedroom apartment in Rathfarnham, Dublin 14, with his wife, their daughter Lia, and his wife’s mother. Harney operates as a self-employed videographer, while his wife works part-time and is actively seeking employment as a clerical officer.
The Harney family has lived in the same apartment for a decade, witnessing significant rent increases from €1,500 to €1,820 per month during their tenure. Despite the rent pressure zones capping yearly rent hikes at 2%, the increased cost has still pushed the family to their financial limits.
“It’s tough, we’re just about getting by,” Harney admits. He notes that his landlord could theoretically charge much more, but the rent pressure zones have kept their costs in check, albeit barely.
The Eviction Notice and Attempted Resolutions
In mid-2022, the family received an eviction notice as their landlord desired to sell the property. The landlord offered to sell the apartment to South Dublin County Council (SDCC), which oversees public housing selection.
Harney explains that the application process for SDCC’s purchase took several months. However, after much effort, they learned that the property’s value exceeded SDCC’s allowable purchase price.
Following this setback, the family secured Housing Assistance Payment (HAP) benefits to ease their rent burden, making them eligible for the Tenant in Situ Scheme for HAP recipients. Unfortunately, they did not qualify for this program either.
Searching for New Shelter
With time running out on the eviction notice, the Harney family has embarked on an extensive search for alternative accommodation. Over the past 16 months, they have visited 15 potential rental properties, with each viewing attracting over 20 attendees.
“Each viewing has over 20 people attending, and landlords tend to avoid renting to families with children or those receiving HAP support,” Harney laments.
The couple has also explored emergency accommodation options but found no viable solutions given their work situation and personal circumstances.
The Harney Family’s Desperate Situation
Paul Harney: ‘In the past 16 months, we’ve viewed 15 rental properties, without success. Each viewing has over 20 people attending, and landlords tend to avoid renting to families with children or those receiving HAP support.’
Photograph: Dara Mac Dónaill/The Irish Times
Harney’s work-from-home setup complicates their search for new accommodation. He uses the spare room to store his work equipment, making it impractical to relocate to temporary housing solutions like hostels.
“There’s no other outlet for me unless I get another rental. I can’t afford to buy.” Harney emphasizes his limited options.
While he has observed a slight uptick in rental listings compared to the previous year, the increased demand means competition is fierce. “There’s a fear there, absolutely. We look for places around the clock, I have a viewing today and another on Friday… we are looking around the clock, but nobody is getting back to us. The effort never ends.”
The Broader Implications
The Harney family’s story highlights the broader housing crisis in Ireland, where rising rent prices and limited rental options have disproportionately affected low to moderate-income families.
South Dublin County Council, tasked with providing affordable housing, has been unable to mitigate the eviction threat for the Harney family. The council’s limitations in property purchasing further exacerbate the challenges faced by families in similar situations.
Government policies such as rent pressure zones and HAP benefits offer temporary relief but do not address the fundamental issues underlying Dublin’s housing market.
Call to Action
The Harney family’s plight underscores the urgent need for comprehensive housing legislation to protect vulnerable homeowners from eviction and ensure access to affordable rental options. As the situation unfolds, it is crucial for policymakers, community advocates, and the public to support initiatives aimed at alleviating the housing crisis.
We invite readers to share their thoughts and experiences related to housing challenges in the comments section below. Your insights and support can contribute to fostering a more inclusive dialogue on housing reform.
Your voice matters.
Share your thoughts, subscribe for our updates, and spread awareness.
