It’s a week marked by the surprises experienced
the promotion of the Star Academy 2025. After a bonus which was unanimously appreciated by the teachers on Friday November 14, which brought together four generations of academics, the students only had one day of respite.
Sunday afternoon and Monday morning, they were in front of the faculty to take their fifth evaluation. As we can see in the daily which was broadcast on November 18 on TF1, the teachers were very disappointed by the performance of an academician, who was often at the top of the ranking.
Star Academy 2025: surprise evaluations at the castle
If there are many twists and turns at Star Academy, the students were taken by surprise by an unexpected announcement from the director on Sunday, November 16, a few hours after the prime debrief. Michael Goldman announced to the academics that they had one hour to prepare their evaluations, with a song that they were going to draw lots. Ambre, Anouk, Bastiaan, Léa, Léane and Jeanne were evaluated on Sunday. For their part, Léo, Sarah, Victor, Mélissa, Lily, Théo L and Théo P passed in front of the teaching staff Monday morning, under the same conditions.
These evaluations created surprise among the students, but also among the teachers, in both good and bad ways. Some academics enjoyed working in a hurry and being quickly relieved of this stress, and others did not manage to prepare in time, especially since they did not all know the song drawn at random.
Star Academy 2025: a student completely fails his assessment and shocks the teachers
For example, Victor drew “That you come back” by Patrick Fiori. While he regularly excelled during his evaluations, he was very disappointed with his proposal: “Well, I’m going to be nominated”he said, joining the students. The teachers are also very disappointed: “I want to cry”says Michael Goldman, once alone with the faculty. Marlène Schaff shares her opinion: “This is a disaster. There is nothing. There is nothing. I don’t understand what happened to him. There is no structure. He makes mistakes in the text while the text is before his eyes. The verses, he never sang the right melody, but never. He sings out of tune at the end of his verses. Rhythmically, he’s wrong too, he’s been wrong all the time.”
No one understands how he could have failed his assessment so much: “It’s sabotage” laments the director. The same evening, viewers will learn that Victor is one of the three named, with Léane and Théo P.
