The quest for college football’s ultimate individual honor, the Heisman Trophy, has always captivated fans and pundits alike. While numerous players have showcased exceptional skills, few have parlayed a Heisman win into a successful professional career in the NFL. Recent examples include DeVonta Smith of Alabama and LSU’s Joe Burrow, both of whom not only claimed the Heisman but also went on to win major championships in the NFL.
DeVonta Smith, the wide receiver from Alabama, recently added another crown to his trophy case by winning Super Bowl LXVIII with the Philadelphia Eagles. Meanwhile, Joe Burrow’s exceptional comeback season was recognized with an NFL Comeback Player of the Year award. These are just some of the shining examples of the lasting impact a Heisman Trophy can have on a player’s career.
A Look Ahead to 2025
As the 2024 college football season concludes, attention naturally shifts to the next year’s contenders for the Heisman Trophy. An interesting trend over the past few years is that many recent winners have transferred at least once during their collegiate careers. However, the top three favorites for the 2025 season have remained with their original schools, positioning themselves well to potentially take home the trophy.
Key players like Garrett Nussmeier from LSU and Arch Manning from Texas have developed without the distractions of transfers, providing them with continuity and depth of experience. These players now have the opportunity to showcase their skills and potentially set themselves apart as strong Heisman contenders.
Top Contenders vs. Pretenders for the Heisman
With the season still over six months away, it’s crucial to separate potential winners into two categories: Contenders and Pretenders. Here, we take a closer look at the top six betting favorites and their respective odds from FanDuel Sportsbook.
Garrett Nussmeier, QB, LSU
Odds: +800 | Status: Contender
Nussmeier leads the Heisman favorites odds and for good reason. As LSU’s starting quarterback, he threw for 4,052 yards and 29 touchdowns in his first full year, displaying exceptional skill and consistency. LSU quarterbacks have a history of winning the Heisman in their second year as starters, with Joe Burrow and Jayden Daniels serving as notable examples. If Nussmeier can reduce turnovers and leverage improved receiving depth, he could follow in their footsteps.
Arch Manning, QB, Texas
Odds: +900 | Status: Contender
Manning’s prospects have soared, with valid reasons beyond just carrying the Manning legacy. Despite being in limited action last season due to Quinn Ewers’ injury, he threw for 806 yards and eight touchdowns in just three games. Even when Ewers was healthy, Manning was brought in for special offensive packages. His combination of pass and rush potential makes him a strong candidate for Heisman honors.
Klubnik, QB, Clemson
Odds: +1000 | Status: Contender
Klubnik had a breakout 2024 season, throwing for 3,639 yards and 36 touchdowns while also rushing for 463 yards and seven scores. His success helped Clemson win the ACC title and make a College Football Playoff appearance. With Antonio Williams returning as the team’s leading receiver, Klubnik’s profile could grow even more if he maintains his current performance level.
CJ Moore, QB, Oregon
Odds: +1200 | Status: Pretender
Moore remains a wildcard. While he possesses the physical attributes to be a star, his inconsistent performance at UCLA as a true freshman and his subsequent transfer to Oregon leave many skeptical. Oregon’s strong offensive system and Coach Dan Lanning’s guidance could unlock Moore’s potential, but as of now, he’s more of a long shot.
George Smith, WR, Ohio State
Odds: +1200 | Status: Contender
Smith’s breakout 2024 season as a true freshman wide receiver couldn’t be more impressive. With 15 touchdowns and 1,315 receiving yards, he quickly became Ohio State’s go-to option, even in post-season games. His continued growth will be key to his Heisman campaign.
Frankie Iamaleava, QB, Tennessee
Odds: +1400 | Status: Pretender
Iamaleava’s first year as Tennessee’s starting quarterback was mixed, with inconsistent performance and a lack of overall effectiveness. While his raw talent is evident, he lacks experience and faces challenges with a depleted receiving corps. Significant improvement is needed for him to become a genuine Heisman threat.
Longshots to Watch
While consensus Heisman winners typically come from the top-ranked contenders, there are always players who can surprise the field. Here are a few longshots to keep an eye on:
LaNorris Sellers, QB, South Carolina (+1800)
At 6 feet 3 inches and 242 pounds, Sellers accounted for 3,208 total yards and 25 touchdowns in 2024, seven of which were on the ground. His combination of size, arm strength, and rushing ability makes him a player to watch.
DJ Lagway, QB, Florida (+2000)
Lagway emerged as a key player after Graham Mertz’s injury, showing enough promise as a true freshman to warrant continued attention. While his stats may not be eye-catching yet, he possesses the skills necessary to become a premier quarterback.
Sam Leavitt, QB, Arizona State (+3300)
Arizona State’s success hinges on Leavitt’s performance. Known for his playmaking ability, Leavitt could lead the Sun Devils to a repeat of their breakout 2024 season.
Ryan Williams, WR, Alabama (+4000)
Williams made significant contributions as a freshman, showing what he could do when given opportunities. As he gains more experience, his potential as a Heisman candidate could rise.
Conclusion
Predicting the Heisman Trophy winner is like predicting any major college football game—the unpredictability is what makes it exciting. While Garrett Nussmeier and Arch Manning are the leading contenders, players like Klubnik and George Smith also have a strong chance. Keep an eye on the longshots, too. The 2025 season promises to be filled with exciting performances and potential Heisman moments.
Which player do you think will take home the 2025 Heisman Trophy? Let us know your thoughts in the comments below, and don’t forget to subscribe to our newsletter for the latest updates on college football and the Heisman race.
