Does South Africa Need Refineries Without Oil or Gas Reserves?
South Africa, a nation devoid of significant oil and gas reserves, is grappling with the decision to refurbish the Mossel Bay gas refinery. The initiative, once deemed promising with a substantial investment from Russian financier Gazprombank, is now in flux, prompting skepticism from experts and political observers alike.
Mossel Bay Refinery Refurbishment Deal Collapses
In December 2023, the South African government approved a R3.7 billion deal with Gazprombank to refurbish the Mossel Bay gas-to-liquid fuel refinery, which ceased operations in 2020 due to a lack of feedstock. However, recent developments suggest that the deal may not come to fruition. The Russian bank, Gazprombank, has failed to deliver the promised funding, and Equator Holdings, the South African partner, has faced financial irregularities, including liquidation.
Equator Holdings, managed by Lawrence Mulaudzi, a politically connected businessman, was involved in a massive tender deal despite having no track record in the gas industry. The company did not provide proof of the R22 billion needed to finance the deal, a requirement for securing the contract. Moreover, Equator Holdings was liquidated in March 2024 for failing to pay a soccer player, yet PetroSA remained unaware of this development.
Political Interference and Contractual Issues
Critics argue that political interference and possible nefarious activities are at play in the tender process. The Democratic Alliance (DA) submitted a PAIA application to obtain the record of decision-making behind the tender award to Equator Holdings. The issues extend beyond just the lack of financial credibility of Equator Holdings. Disputes and claims of corruption have also marred the procurement process.
Wayne Duvenage, CEO of Outa, expresses concerns over the financial viability of the project. “It appears that the gas supply plan is a problem, and we have no doubt that political interference and possible nefarious activities are at play,” he stated, emphasizing the critical nature of gas availability for any refinery operation.
Expert Queries Refinery Necessity
Chirs Yelland, managing director of EE Business Intelligence and an energy expert, questions whether South Africa needs refineries given its lack of oil or gas reserves. “You cannot restart the Mossel Bay refinery refurbishment because it relies on a supply of gas that was going to come from the Brulpadda and Luiperd gas fields,” Yelland said, highlighting the challenges associated with securing a consistent gas supply.
He also points out that Total Energies, a major player in the gas field sector, has withdrawn from the Brulpadda and Luiperd projects, further complicating the plans. The expert notes various other contracting issues and disputes that have plagued the process, contributing to its failure.
The Economic Case for Refining
Yelland argues that refurbishing the Mossel Bay refinery is not economically viable without a steady gas supply. “If we had the resources of gas and a refinery that was in good shape, it would be a good thing for South Africa, but it does not,” he explained. He notes that all other refineries in South Africa are either defunct or inefficient, requiring modernization.
Importantly, Yelland questions whether the costs involved in refurbishment can be justified when liquid fuels are available in excess on the world market. “There is no shortage of liquid fuels globally, so we must ask if it makes sense to produce our own fuel,” he said. The economic implications of such a project are significant, considering the high costs involved and the potential price increases for consumers.
The Cost and Impact on Petrol Prices
The expert warns that the economic burden of refurbishing the refinery would be substantial. “If we invest billions to get these refineries up and running, it means the fuel price will have to increase for these companies to recover their costs over time,” Yelland stated. The increased fuel prices could have a cascading effect on the broader economy, affecting the affordability of fuel for South African citizens.
Furthermore, South Africa’s lack of crude oil resources means it would have to import oil for refining, adding to transportation and refining costs. Yelland emphasizes that, without a competitive advantage, South Africa cannot compete on the global market as a fuel exporter.
Focus on Core Competencies
Yelland recommends that South Africa redirect its focus to its core competencies rather than attempting to become a local manufacturer in the refining sector. “We should become good at importing and logistics, with very good logistical facilities, pipelines, and port facilities,” he said. This shift would leverage South Africa’s existing strengths in logistics and transportation.
Modernizing the refining industry would require significant investment in infrastructure and technology, which Yelland believes would be more effectively applied to enhancing South Africa’s existing capabilities in the logistics and distribution sector. “The reality is that South Africa does not have crude oil, and importing refined products is a more feasible solution,” he concluded.
Conclusion: A Premature and Costly Venture
South Africa’s attempt to refurbish the Mossel Bay refinery is fraught with challenges, including political interference, lack of gas supply, and economic infeasibility. Experts argue that the country should focus on leveraging its strengths in logistics rather than pursuing a costly and potentially futile venture in refining. The question remains whether the motives behind this decision are driven by economic considerations or political agendas.
As South Africa navigates this complex issue, it is crucial for government and industry stakeholders to make informed decisions that align with the country’s economic priorities. The future of South Africa’s energy sector relies on a pragmatic approach that maximizes efficiency and ensures long-term sustainability.
We invite you to share your thoughts on this topic. Join the discussion by commenting below, subscribing to our newsletter for more insights, or follow us on social media to stay updated on the latest news and opinions.
