Minerba Bill: Controversy Over Granting Mining Permits to Universities
TEMPO.CO, Jakarta – The recent approval of the Legislative Body’s (Baleg) proposal on the revision of the Law on Minerals and Coal, known as the Minerba Bill, has sparked intense debate in Indonesia. One of the bill’s most contentious aspects is the granting of mining business permits (IUP) to universities. Critics argue that this move prioritizes certain elites over the broader Indonesian public and fails to address critical environmental and economic issues.
Ruang Setara Project Founder’s Criticisms
Aulia Hakim, the founder of Ruang Setara Project, strongly opposes the granting of mining permits to universities. In a written statement on January 25, 2025, Hakim argued that empowering regional companies, local unions, or nationalizing mining assets from the private sector would be more beneficial approaches. He emphasized that allowing universities to manage mines would not necessarily improve education; instead, it would likely continue elitist practices and fail to address funding challenges.
“The natural resources should be used for the welfare of all Indonesians, not for the benefit of certain groups,” Hakim contended. “Granting mining permits to universities does not ensure that those institutions can manage mining operations effectively or that they will use the revenue to support the broader community.” Hakim also highlighted the environmental impact of mining, citing a case in Central Sulawesi where mining activities have resulted in deforestation and ecological disasters like floods and landslides.
Government’s Perspective
The government’s rationale for the proposal stems from its belief that universities managing mines could improve educational standards. According to Bob Hasan, Chairman of the DPR RI Legislation Body, granting mining permits to universities is part of an effort to enhance the quality of education in Indonesia.
“The government understands that improving education requires significant financial resources for facilities and infrastructure,” Bob explained. “Granting IUPs to universities may provide a way to generate the necessary funds while also boosting the business acumen of academic institutions.” However, critics like Alfarhat Kasman of the Mining Advocacy Network argue that this approach does not genuinely address educational needs and may burden universities with additional financial responsibilities.
DPR and Public Input
Amidst the controversy, DPR Speaker Puan Maharani emphasized that the Minerba Bill followed standard legislative procedures. While she acknowledges concerns, Puan stressed the importance of meaningful participation and public input.
“We have involved leadership meetings and the Consultative Body in the legislative process,” Puan stated. “The DPR Legislation Body will continue to gather feedback from various stakeholders, including experts and academic institutions, to ensure that the final bill meets the needs of all Indonesians.” Puan assured that the DPR is open to receiving input from campuses and other relevant parties.
Broader Implications
The Minerba Bill’s approval has not only sparked debates over the management of mining permits but also raises questions about the government’s approach to resource allocation and environmental stewardship. Critics argue that prioritizing university management of mines may overlook existing environmental degradation and fail to empower local communities, workers, and regional companies.
As discussions continue, it remains to be seen how the Minerba Bill will be implemented and whether it will effectively address the issues it aims to tackle. The future of mining in Indonesia hangs in the balance, with potential implications for economic growth, environmental sustainability, and social development.
Editor’s Choice: BEM UI Rejects Permission for Universities to Manage Mining
Click here to get the latest news updates from Tempo on Google News
What Do You Think?
We value your opinions on this contentious issue. Share your thoughts in the comments section below. Join our community and stay informed about the latest news and developments in Indonesia’s mining sector.
