Children Three Times More Likely to Develop Mental Health Issues if Sibling Experienced Adversity in First 1,000 Days

A new study led by researchers from University College London (UCL) reveals that children born after a sibling who experienced adversity in their first critical 1,000 days of life are nearly three-quarters more likely to develop mental health problems between the ages of five and eighteen. This significant finding highlights the far-reaching impact of early childhood adversity on family mental health.

The Study and Its Key Findings

The study, published in The Lancet Public Health, analyzed health records from over 333,000 first-time mothers and their 534,904 children in England between 2002 and 2018. Researchers focused on six forms of adversity experienced by firstborns during their first 1,000 days: child maltreatment, intimate partner violence, maternal substance misuse, maternal mental health problems, adverse family environments, and high-risk presentations of child maltreatment.

Notably, over a third of firstborn children (37.1%) had at least one adverse experience, with maternal mental health problems being the most prevalent (21.6%), followed by adverse family environments (14.5%). The study found that approximately one in five mothers (19.8%) had at least one child who developed mental health issues between the ages of five and eighteen.

The Impact on Subsequent Siblings

The research revealed that mothers whose firstborns experienced adversity were significantly more likely to have subsequent children with mental health problems. Specifically, these mothers had an average of 30 children with mental health issues per 100 mothers, compared to 17 children per 100 mothers whose firstborns did not experience adversity.

This risk remained consistent across all siblings, regardless of birth order. This indicates that the broader family context plays a crucial role in child mental health outcomes.

The Broader Implications

This likely stems from the continuation of adverse childhood experiences within the family. When a child or parent presents with mental health concerns, violence, or other forms of adversity, it’s essential to consider the wider family context.”

Professor Jessica Deighton from UCL’s Psychology & Language Sciences and Anna Freud, a mental health charity for children and young people, emphasized the need for early and effective prevention strategies. “With escalating rates of children and young people in contact with mental health services, focusing on the whole family is key. We must provide appropriate care as early as possible for all children within families dealing with adversity,” Deighton noted.

She called for increased funding for prevention schemes and the use of community resources such as GPs and local organizations to identify and meet the needs of vulnerable young people. Deighton also advocated for the development of a comprehensive, cross-government mental health prevention strategy in collaboration with diverse groups of children and young people.

Future Research Directions

The team is calling for further research to understand the impact of early health visiting and primary care support. Professor Ruth Gilbert, the senior author from UCL’s Great Ormond Street Institute of Child Health, expressed interest in assessing whether early community support from health visitors, GPs, and parenting support programs can reduce mental health problems in families affected by adversity.

Professor Gene Feder from the University of Bristol’s Centre for Academic Primary Care highlighted the role of general practice teams in identifying first-born children experiencing adversity and supporting first-time parents. He emphasized the need for evidence-based interventions to address the issue.

Study Limitations

While the study found a correlation between adverse childhood experiences in firstborns and mental health outcomes in subsequent children, it does not establish causation. Additionally, electronic health-care records may underestimate the prevalence of certain adverse experiences due to non-disclosure or under-recording by clinicians.

Conclusion and Call to Action

The findings of this study underscore the importance of addressing early childhood adversity not only for the individual child but the entire family. By providing early support and prevention strategies, we can significantly improve mental health outcomes for children and young people.

Join the conversation and share your thoughts on how we can better support families dealing with adversity. Subscribe to our newsletter for more updates on mental health and related research.