The Impact of Comedian Tony Hinchcliffe’s Remarks on Puerto Rican Voters in Swing States
The remarks made by comedian Tony Hinchcliffe at a Donald Trump rally, calling Puerto Rico a "floating island of garbage," have sparked significant backlash and are likely to sway votes in the upcoming U.S. election, particularly among Puerto Rican voters in swing states.
Understanding Puerto Rico’s Voting Role
Pennsylvania, with nearly 500,000 Puerto Rican residents, holds particular significance. This minority group’s votes are crucial given the state’s 19 electoral college votes and its hotly contested political landscape. Biden won Pennsylvania by a narrow margin of fewer than 80,000 votes in 2020.
Puerto Rico is a U.S. territory, with its inhabitants being U.S. citizens entitled to vote in federal elections. However, the island often feels excluded and disenfranchised, which Hinchcliffe’s comments have exacerbated.
Reactions from Puerto Rican Community Leaders
Several prominent members of the Puerto Rican community have expressed anger and offense over Hinchcliffe’s comments:
- Victor Martinez: Radio host and owner of five stations in Pennsylvania, Martinez shared that Hinchcliffe’s joke enraged his audience. Comments from listeners ranged from shock to outright condemnation.
- Yesenia Westerband: A food truck owner and native of Puerto Rico, Westerband emphasized the hurtful nature of the joke. Her customers and even those generally apolitical are now engaged in the political conversation.
- Guillermo Lopez: A former union leader and vice chair of The Hispanic Center Lehigh Valley, Lopez noted that the comments galvanized a formerly quiescent group of Puerto Rican voters, prompting more people to engage in politics and potentially switch their votes.
Trump’s Campaign Response
The Trump campaign initially distanced itself from Hinchcliffe’s remarks but has been criticized for not addressing the controversy more robustly. Though the Trump team sought to maintain calm, the incident is seen as a potential liability in the deepening election battle.
Trump himself did not address the controversy directly, focusing instead on other aspects of his campaign and maintaining that he disavows any part in Hinchcliffe’s joke. These slight remarks have failed to placate Puerto Rican voters who see the comments as a further indication of Trump’s disregard for the island and its people.
Elevating Puerto Rican Engagement
Many Puerto Ricans are feeling newly awakened politically and are eager to cast their votes:
- Westerband, a Democrat, is not yet swayed definitively but ensures that Hinchcliffe’s comments are on her mind. Many of her customers, who were previously unengaged with politics, are now actively considering their votes.
- Lopez reports a similar trend among his uninvolved peers. The “garbage” comment has acted like a "bat signal," motivating them to exit their political apathy and engage with the election process.
Consequences and Final Thoughts
Experts suggest that the fallout from Hinchrife’s remarks could alienate swing voters, particularly Puerto Rican ones. In a contest as close as the current presidential race, even a small shift in the undecided vote could tip the scales.
As we approach the end of the campaign, attention to such incidents will likely be crucial. The Trump campaign’s projection of calm and denial has failed to entirely set minds at ease. Instead, the remarks have become a central point of the conversation, drawing more damage than it could have prevented.
Call to Action:
Watch this space for further developments. Sign up to receive election updates and get your questions answered by the USA TODAY elections team. Sign up here. Stay informed and keep the conversations going on all major political developments leading up to election day.