Top 15 MLB Players Considered for 2025 Contract Extensions

The MLB free agent market saw significant movement as Alex Bregman and Nick Pivetta signed with the Boston Red Sox and San Diego Padres, respectively. With the majority of the Top 25 free agents off the board, attention now shifts to players who might ink contract extensions with their current teams. These extensions serve multiple purposes, from locking up young talent early to securing veteran players before they hit free agency.

Entering his age-28 season, Arraez is preparing to become a free agent after the 2025 season. Known for his batting prowess with an impressive .323 lifetime batting average and two consecutive 200-hit seasons, Arraez is a prime candidate for a multi-year deal. The Padres, who recently acquired Michael King and Dylan Cease, might be eager to secure Arraez’s services amidst their upcoming financial restructuring.

At 26, Hunter Brown represents future potential for the Astros. Despite a challenging 2023, his performance improved significantly in 2024 with a 3.49 ERA over 170 innings. Given the team’s history of signing pre-arb players, Brown is a strong candidate for an extension, ensuring continuity for Houston’s pitching staff.

Butler’s breakout 2024 campaign, where he hit 22 home runs and 18 stolen bases, positions him as a key figure for the Athletics. With significant investments in other players like Luis Severino and Jeffrey Springs, the team might consider locking Butler into a long-term deal. This move could solidify the Athletics’ future as they transition to a new stadium in Las Vegas.

The Red Sox obtained Crochet in a trade that involved giving up promising prospects. With just one season as a starter under his belt, Crochet’s future is exciting. The team will likely be cautious, waiting for consistent performance before committing to a long-term deal, balancing his potential with financial constraints.

Cruz’s successful 2024 season, a bounce-back from a leg fracture in 2023, positions him as a valuable asset for the Pirates. Given the team’s history of retaining young players like Ke’Bryan Hayes, Bryan Reynolds, and Mitch Keller, Cruz is a prime candidate for an extension. His versatility and recent field performance make him a vital piece of the team’s plan.

The Rockies’ interest in extending Doyle, winner of the Gold Glove Award twice, demonstrates their commitment to retaining young stars. Doyle’s value extends beyond the field, offering a significant impact in丫 defensive plays. With his arbitration years approaching, the Rockies might prioritize a long-term commitment to Doyle.

Gilbert, 28, had a standout season in 2024, earning All-Star honors and setting records with his innings pitched and WHIP. His path to free agency comes in 2027, making him the Mariners’ top extension candidate among young pitching prospects. With a strong resume, Gilbert could command significant attention from Seattle.

The fifth overall pick in 2019, Greene’s breakout in 2024 as a 23-year-old is setting off alarms. Displaying an .827 OPS and winning an All-Star nod, Greene is poised for an extension. The Tigers, who value pre-arb deals, may see value in locking Greene into a contract that includes multiple arbitration years.

Extension talks with Guerrero have stalled, with both sides far apart. Guerrero’s ability to generate high-value offers makes him a critical target for the Blue Jays, with negotiation tensions likely to intensify as Spring Training approaches. The market’s recent pricing trends suggest Guerrero could be seeking a contract exceeding $400 million, making him a unique challenge.

Merrill’s debut season was exceptional, showing his potential. San Diego’s history of pre-arb extensions, as seen with Fernando Tatis Jr., hints at another deal possibility. With Merrill’s arbitration eligibility coming in 2026, the Padres might look to secure his services early to avoid future costs.

Behind the plate, Raleigh provided leadership and defense, winning the AL Platinum Glove award. His arbitration years end in 2027, making him a valuable candidate for an extension. Raleigh’s role in guiding the Mariners’ young staff makes him a priority for Seattle’s long-term plans.

Entering 2025, Realmuto’s contract with the Phillies ends, making him eligible for free agency. His defensive prowess and leadership make him an essential player for Philadelphia, with the franchise potentially exploring options to retain his services.

With a final season in his current deal approaching, Schwarber’s future with the Phillies is uncertain. As a clubhouse leader and prolific slugger, Schwarber’s value could lead to discussions about extending his contract beyond 2025. However, his role as the designated hitter complicates negotiations.

Rutschman, 27, serves as the anchor of Baltimore’s young core, with his offensive production and leadership vital to the team’s success. His representation by Wasserman and the Orioles’ potential financial flexibility provide favorable conditions for an extension, ensuring stability for the franchise.

The Cubs acquired Tucker through a trade, eyeing his three-time All-Star status and offensive contributions. With Dallas Swanson being the only player signed beyond 2027, Chicago’s payroll offers flexibility to secure Tucker’s services long-term. The Cubs will likely aim to close a deal before Tucker’s 2025 free agency eligibility.