Conclave Undercurrents: Echoes of Past Disinformation Campaigns

As the conclave progresses, echoes of past controversies resonate, particularly concerning the spread of misinformation aimed at influencing the selection of the next Pope.Similar to scenarios depicted in films like Edward Berger’s work, and reminiscent of past attempts to discredit Pope Bergoglio by questioning his health, a new wave of disinformation has emerged, targeting Cardinal Pietro Parolin, a prominent figure in the current proceedings.

The Allegation: A Health Scare During a Critical Period

An American website, catholicvote.org, recently published a report alleging that Cardinal Parolin experienced a health incident on April 30th, towards the end of a General Congregation session in the Vatican. The report claimed that Cardinal Parolin reportedly “passed out,” causing immediate concern among his colleagues and Vatican staff. This details, if true, coudl significantly impact his standing within the conclave.

Vatican Denies claims: “Absolutely False”

The Holy See swiftly responded to these allegations, categorically denying the report’s accuracy. Matteo Bruni, director of the Holy See Press Office, issued a statement refuting the claims, labeling them as “false.” This rapid rebuttal underscores the sensitivity surrounding the conclave and the potential for misinformation to disrupt the process.

No, it’s not true.

matteo Bruni, Director of the Holy See Press Office

Cardinal Parolin: A Key Figure in the conclave

Cardinal parolin, a 70-year-old prelate from veneto, is widely regarded as a close confidant of Pope Francis and a seasoned Vatican diplomat.His extensive experience in international relations makes him a significant figure in the conclave, although some perceive him as less charismatic than his Argentine counterpart. The attempt to discredit him highlights the high stakes involved in the papal election.

The Broader Context: disinformation and the Papal Election

The spread of disinformation during papal elections is not a new phenomenon. Historically, various factions have sought to influence the outcome through rumors, leaks, and outright falsehoods. The digital age has amplified these challenges, making it easier for misinformation to spread rapidly and widely. The Vatican’s swift response in this case demonstrates its awareness of the threat and its commitment to maintaining the integrity of the conclave process. According to a 2024 study by the Pew Research Center, 64% of adults believe fabricated news and information cause a great deal of confusion.