Housing Crisis: New Irish Government Faces Fresh Challenges
The newly formed Irish government has encountered immediate setbacks in its housing agenda. Two critical reports have cast a shadow over the administration’s early efforts to address the housing crisis.
Housing Completions Lag Behind
Recent statistics revealed that housing completions in 2024 totaled 30,330 units. This number is significantly lower than the 40,000 units predicted by senior ministers during the election campaign. Analysts had already warned that hitting this target was unlikely, but the results are still disheartening.
Construction Consultancy Offers Grim Forecast
The situation appears even more troubling according to a report by Mitchell McDermott, a leading construction consultancy. The report suggests that completions may only reach 32,000 units in 2025, a scenario that other forecasters consider overly pessimistic. Goodbody analyst Dermot O’Leary offers a marginally more optimistic outlook, predicting 34,000 completions for this year.
Housing Targets vs. Reality
Just two weeks ago, in its Programme for Government, the new Coalition outlined ambitious plans to construct 300,000 homes by the end of 2030. This strategy aligns with the previous administration’s goal set in November 2023, aiming for an average of 50,500 new homes annually. The target for housing completions in 2025 was set at 41,000 units. The latest data paints a stark contrast to these aspirational targets.
Against this backdrop of minimal supply, the Banking and Payments Federation reports a surge in first-time buyer mortgage approvals, signaling strong demand. Falling interest rates compound the problem, likely driving prices upwards.
The Supply Dilemma
Last year’s housing completions figures were disconcerting for the previous government, but hopes for this year’s performance were not realized. A surge in housing commencement notices, 60,000 in total, was partly due to incentives such as waivers on development levies and rebates on water charges for homes started before the end of 2024.
However, Paul Mitchell from Mitchell McDermott highlights an irony: while developers may lodge commencement notices for large projects, the actual number of units started is much lower. Developers aim to maximize their eligibility for incentives but are not obligated to finish as many units as stated in their notices.
This issue points to the broader challenge the government faces in balancing state-supported housing programs with unpredictable private sector output.
Identifying the Blockages
The government continues to face long-standing impediments in planning and finance. Central Statistics Office data shows that apartment completions fell by 24% in 2024, while housing scheme completions increased by 4.6% to 16,200 units, and once-off housing completions decreased by 2.2% to 5,367.
Several factors contribute to the challenges in apartment construction. These include high construction costs, reduced international investment due to rising interest rates, and the impact of rent caps on returns.
International investors withdrew significantly during the rental cap debate, indicating that the political climate affects long-term investments. State agencies like the Land Development Agency, local authorities, and Approved Housing Bodies have partially填补led the gap, although at a cost.
The government must address these issues to attract sustainable investment in apartment building while balancing state provision to enhance affordability.
First-Time Buyers in a Tight Market
The market for first-time buyers is buoyant, with record approvals for mortgages. However, a severe shortage of available properties and high demand exacerbate the situation. Mortgage broker Michael Dowling explains that first-time buyers are often forced to outbid each other, driving prices higher.
Furthermore, Approved Housing Bodies are increasingly entering the market to increase supply of social and affordable homes, adding another layer of competition for new properties.
Analyst John Fahy suggests that first-time buyer prices may increase by around 10% in 2025, while others predict a more moderate rise of 5%. Regardless, experts agree that prices will likely continue to rise.
With the First Home Scheme providing state equity stakes in homes, buyers must consider the long-term financial implications of these arrangements.
Future Outlook and Policy Challenges
The housing crisis in Ireland remains complex, with various policy issues requiring attention. The government’s new Planning Act aims to streamline the process, but a comprehensive national planning framework is still under development, due for release in the summer.
Given the current market dynamics, the government faces pressure to address immediate supply issues while working on long-term solutions to stabilize prices and increase affordability.
The Commission on Housing has provided recommendations on rent caps, financing challenges, and planning reforms, offering valuable insights for policymakers.
Conclusion
The early challenges faced by the new Irish government in addressing the housing crisis emphasize the complexity of the issue. Improving housing completions and meeting ambitious targets will require a strategic approach, addressing planning delays, financial constraints, and investment challenges effectively.
As the market continues to evolve, the government must balance immediate needs with long-term vision to provide sustainable housing solutions for all Irish citizens.
Stay informed as we continue to report on these developments.
[ Housing delivery predicted to stagnate and fall well short of targetsOpens in new window ]
Join the Conversation
What are your thoughts on Ireland’s housing crisis? Share your insights in the comments below. Don’t forget to subscribe to stay updated on the latest news and analysis.