Eurovision Controversies: Eurosong Panel Criticism and Song Submission Confusion
Emmy’s entry ‘Laika Party’ had been sent to Norway’s Melodi Grand Prix prior to submission in Ireland’s national song contest.
The Song Submission Controversy
In the world of Eurovision, strict rules govern song submissions to ensure fairness across all participating countries. RTÉ, Ireland’s national broadcaster, has a specific rule stating that any song put forward by performers “must not be submitted for consideration to any other country participating in Eurovision Song Contest 2025.”
Emmy, the performer in question, initially developed the song during a songwriting camp in Norway linked to Melodi Grand Prix (MGP). According to Emmy, all songs created at the camp were “automatically sent to MGP along with a hundred other songs, but it wasn’t like we actively sent it in there.” Emmy further clarified that the song, although submitted for consideration, was not accepted for performance.
RTÉ argues that their rule is straightforward. RTÉ spokespersons maintain that the rule is in place “to prevent the same performer or song competing in both Late Late Show Eurosong and another televised selection show such as Melodi Grand Prix (MGP).” They added that the broadcaster has the final say on any song and performer’s eligibility for Ireland’s Eurovision entry.
Nevertheless, RTÉ acknowledges that this is not the case with Emmy and her song Laika Party. The broadcaster and the EBU will retain the final decision on the application of the rules.
Panels and Politics: Eurosong Feedback Controversy
The Eurosong televisions show has faced another round of controversy following a public disagreement between contestant Samantha Mumba and three panel members.
Mumba criticized judges Donal Skehan, Laura Fox, and Arthur Gourounlian, describing them as “a trio of bozos” whose comments were “vile.” In a passionate Instagram post, Mumba offered the panel what she called her “parting gift” to them — a playful suggestion of choking on a bag of aubergine emojis. The controversy sparked immediate backlash and caused concern among the remaining contestants.
Another contestant, Reylta, whose real name is Caoimhe Glynn, chimed in on the matter. She told Newstalk radio that the panellists’ comments created a tense atmosphere backstage, leading to emotional upset among the performers.
The Role of the Eurosong Panel
Ireland’s Eurosong process is unique in its inclusion of a panel of experts, whose role is entirely advisory with no impact on the overall scoring. The panel has been a significant part of the Eurosong show, taking up over half of the two-hour program to provide commentary and feedback.
The inclusion of experts on the panel has drawn mixed reactions from the Eurosong contestants. Samantha Mumba’s criticism highlights the impact of such feedback on the delicate Contest environment.
Panelist Donal Skehan defended the process, stating that tearing down performers is unproductive. He emphasized the panel’s effort to ensure a fair and constructive process for all contestants.
Former Eurovision winner Niamh Kavanagh offered a balanced perspective. While she understands the logistics behind having a panel, she suggests that the role of the panel may merit review. Kavanagh disagrees with the concept of including a panel with no influence on the final outcome.
Conclusion
The controversies surrounding both song submission rules and panel feedback in Ireland’s Eurosong selection process highlight the delicate nature of Eurovision traditions. While the intentions behind these measures are clear, the execution sometimes leads to unintended conflicts and criticisms.
As Ireland prepares for Eurovision Song Contest 2025, these issues will undoubtedly continue to shape public opinion and internal discussions within the broadcaster.